It’s a Question of Ethics: RTO and Public Service Culture
Robert P. Shepherd, Amelie Armstrong and Andrea Rounce
National Public Administration Case Competition
The 2025 National Public Administration Case Competition was hosted by Carleton University (SPPA) and held virtually on February 12 to 22, 2025.
The Case Challenge
Public administration is a complex field. The case presented will require teams to go through the stages of case study review:
- The overall policy and operational effects of this series of events to define the problem and issues.
- The risks inherent in responding and in not responding.
- Strategic options with preferred approach.
- Suggestions for the process for moving towards the strategic approach.
- Implementation issues and suggested course of action (including financial implications).
- Issues related to communication, collaboration, stakeholders, and suggested courses of action.
- 2025 Rules and Procedures
- 2025 CAPPA Case
- 2025 Case Competition Program
- 2025 Case Scoring Criteria Rubric
Judges
The competition was judged by:
- Noah Morris (Head Judge) : Principal at NJM Strategies recently retiree. He was Superintendent of Colleges, Director of Student Financial Assistance, Director of Postsecondary Finance and ADM of Postsecondary Education in the Ministry of Colleges and Universities, Chair of the Federal Provincial committee on postsecondary student finance and recipient of 2 personal Amethyst awards for signature public policy achievements in Ontario.
- Suzanne Craig : internationally trained lawyer, Integrity Commissioner, Lobbyist Registrar and Closed Meeting Investigator.
- Nancy Carroll : Civil Service Commissioner, strategic advice on labour relations at Red River College Polytechnic.
- Stefania Trombetti : Executive Director of the Regulatory Governance Initiative and Instructor for the Career Development for Regulatory Professionals Program in the School of Public Policy and Administration at Carleton University.
- Guy Giorno : leads his firm’s Political Law practice, Integrity Commissioner for several Ontario municipalities, co-author of Lobbying in Canada and a former Chair of the Canadian Bar Association’s “Law of Lobbying and Ethics” Committee.
- Michael Presley : adjunct professor, School of Public Policy and
Administration, co-director of the Career Development for Regulatory
Professionals program and director of the certificate program in regulatory leadership at the Centre for Public Management and Policy at the University of Ottawa.
Thank you to all of the judges for sharing their experience, wisdom, and time with the students and their coaches!
The Teams
Fourteen teams from coast to coast participated in the 2024 Case Competition.
Scroll down to see photos of all of the participating teams and their presentation!
Winning Team Presentations
Shepherd Prize:
Concordia University
Team :
Tess walker
Julia Kelly
Hannah Lazarus
Matteo Mazza
Erykah Yasmine Kangbeya
Coaches:
Meghan Joy
Joe Faragone
Silver Prize:
University of Toronto
Team:
Georgia Maxwell
Fadeel Sheikh
Noah Lee
Jean-Pierre Péladeau
Milad Naeim
Coaches:
Drew Fagan
Brian Lewis
Bronze Prize:
York University and University of Calgary
York University team:
Isi Imafidon
Emma-Jane Cowan
Betiel Msghina Abraha
Syeda Nafisa Nawal
Michael Tracey
Milena Basciano
York University coach:
Ian Roberge
University of Calgary team:
Haris Ahmad
Bri Dangerfield
Muneer Nazir
Ty Willness
Serena (Thi) To
University of Calgary coach:
Kent Fellows